게임 이론의 Minimax 알고리즘 | 세트 5(Zobrist 해싱)

이 주제에 대한 이전 게시물: 게임 이론의 미니맥스 알고리즘 게임이론의 평가함수 Tic-Tac-Toe AI – 최적의 움직임 찾기 알파-베타 가지치기 .
Zobrist Hashing은 2인용 보드 게임에서 널리 사용되는 해싱 함수입니다. 전치 테이블에 사용되는 가장 일반적인 해싱 함수입니다. 전치 테이블은 기본적으로 이전 보드 상태의 평가 값을 저장하므로 해당 상태가 다시 발생하면 간단히 전치 테이블에서 저장된 값을 검색합니다. 우리는 이후 기사에서 전치 테이블을 다룰 것입니다. 이 기사에서는 체스판의 예를 들어 이에 대한 해싱 함수를 구현하겠습니다.

유사 코드:

// A matrix with random numbers initialized once Table[#ofBoardCells][#ofPieces] // Returns Zobrist hash function for current conf- // iguration of board.   function   findhash(board): hash = 0   for each   cell on the board :   if   cell is not empty : piece = board[cell] hash ^= table[cell][piece] return hash 

설명 :

Zobrist Hashing의 기본 개념은 주어진 보드 상태에 대해 주어진 셀에 조각이 있는 경우 테이블의 해당 셀에서 해당 조각의 난수를 사용한다는 것입니다. 
난수에 더 많은 비트가 있으면 해시 충돌 가능성이 줄어듭니다. 따라서 64비트 숫자가 일반적으로 표준으로 사용되며 이렇게 큰 숫자에서는 해시 충돌이 발생할 가능성이 거의 없습니다. 테이블은 프로그램 실행 중에 한 번만 초기화되어야 합니다. 
또한 Zobrist Hashing이 보드 게임에서 널리 사용되는 이유는 플레이어가 움직일 때 해시 값을 처음부터 다시 계산할 필요가 없기 때문입니다. XOR 연산의 특성으로 인해 해시 값을 다시 계산하기 위해 몇 가지 XOR 연산을 간단히 사용할 수 있습니다.

구현 :


우리는 주어진 보드 구성에 대한 해시 값을 찾으려고 노력할 것입니다.

CPP
   // A program to illustrate Zobrist Hashing Algorithm   #include      using     namespace     std  ;   unsigned     long     long     int     ZobristTable  [  8  ][  8  ][  12  ];   mt19937     mt  (  01234567  );   // Generates a Random number from 0 to 2^64-1   unsigned     long     long     int     randomInt  ()   {      uniform_int_distribution  &  lt  ;  unsigned     long     long     int  &  gt  ;      dist  (  0       UINT64_MAX  );      return     dist  (  mt  );   }   // This function associates each piece with   // a number   int     indexOf  (  char     piece  )   {      if     (  piece  ==  'P'  )      return     0  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'N'  )      return     1  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'B'  )      return     2  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'R'  )      return     3  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'Q'  )      return     4  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'K'  )      return     5  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'p'  )      return     6  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'n'  )      return     7  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'b'  )      return     8  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'r'  )      return     9  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'q'  )      return     10  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'k'  )      return     11  ;      else      return     -1  ;   }   // Initializes the table   void     initTable  ()   {      for     (  int     i     =     0  ;     i  &  lt  ;  8  ;     i  ++  )      for     (  int     j     =     0  ;     j  &  lt  ;  8  ;     j  ++  )      for     (  int     k     =     0  ;     k  &  lt  ;  12  ;     k  ++  )      ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ][  k  ]     =     randomInt  ();   }   // Computes the hash value of a given board   unsigned     long     long     int     computeHash  (  char     board  [  8  ][  9  ])   {      unsigned     long     long     int     h     =     0  ;      for     (  int     i     =     0  ;     i  &  lt  ;  8  ;     i  ++  )      {      for     (  int     j     =     0  ;     j  &  lt  ;  8  ;     j  ++  )      {      if     (  board  [  i  ][  j  ]  !=  '-'  )      {      int     piece     =     indexOf  (  board  [  i  ][  j  ]);      h     ^=     ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ][  piece  ];      }      }      }      return     h  ;   }   // Main Function   int     main  ()   {      // Uppercase letters are white pieces      // Lowercase letters are black pieces      char     board  [  8  ][  9  ]     =      {      &  quot  ;  ---  K  ----&  quot  ;      &  quot  ;  -  R  ----  Q  -&  quot  ;      &  quot  ;  --------&  quot  ;      &  quot  ;  -  P  ----  p  -&  quot  ;      &  quot  ;  -----  p  --&  quot  ;      &  quot  ;  --------&  quot  ;      &  quot  ;  p  ---  b  --  q  &  quot  ;      &  quot  ;  ----  n  --  k  &  quot  ;      };      initTable  ();      unsigned     long     long     int     hashValue     =     computeHash  (  board  );      printf  (  &  quot  ;  The     hash     value     is     :     %  llu    n  &  quot  ;     hashValue  );      //Move the white king to the left      char     piece     =     board  [  0  ][  3  ];      board  [  0  ][  3  ]     =     '-'  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      board  [  0  ][  2  ]     =     piece  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      printf  (  &  quot  ;  The     new     hash     value     is     :     %  llu    n  &  quot  ;     hashValue  );      // Undo the white king move      piece     =     board  [  0  ][  2  ];      board  [  0  ][  2  ]     =     '-'  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      board  [  0  ][  3  ]     =     piece  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      printf  (  &  quot  ;  The     old     hash     value     is     :     %  llu    n  &  quot  ;     hashValue  );      return     0  ;   }   
Java
   // A Java program to illustrate Zobrist Hashing Algorithm   import     java.util.*  ;   public     class   GFG     {      public     static     List   <  List   <  List   <  Integer  >>>     ZobristTable     =     new     ArrayList   <>  ();      // mt19937 mt(01234567);      public     static     void     initialise  ()     {      for     (  int     i     =     0  ;     i      <     8  ;     i  ++  )     {      ZobristTable  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  ());      for     (  int     j     =     0  ;     j      <     8  ;     j  ++  )     {      ZobristTable  .  get  (  i  ).  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  ());      for     (  int     k     =     0  ;     k      <     12  ;     k  ++  )     {      ZobristTable  .  get  (  i  ).  get  (  j  ).  add  (  0  );      }      }      }      }      // Generates a Random number from 0 to 2^64-1      public     static     long     randomLong  ()     {      long     min     =     0  L  ;      long     max     =     (  long  )     Math  .  pow  (  2       64  );      Random     rnd     =     new     Random  ();      return     rnd  .  nextLong  ()     *     (  max     -     min  )     +     min  ;      }      // This function associates each piece with a number      public     static     int     indexOf  (  char     piece  )         {      if     (  piece  ==  'P'  )      return     0  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'N'  )      return     1  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'B'  )      return     2  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'R'  )      return     3  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'Q'  )      return     4  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'K'  )      return     5  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'p'  )      return     6  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'n'  )      return     7  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'b'  )      return     8  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'r'  )      return     9  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'q'  )      return     10  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'k'  )      return     11  ;      else      return     -  1  ;      }      // Initializes the table      public     static     void     initTable  ()     {      for     (  int     i     =     0  ;     i      <     8  ;     i  ++  )     {      for     (  int     j     =     0  ;     j      <     8  ;     j  ++  )     {      for     (  int     k     =     0  ;     k      <     12  ;     k  ++  )     {      Random     rnd     =     new     Random  ();      ZobristTable  .  get  (  i  ).  get  (  j  ).  set  (  k       (  int  )     randomLong  ());      }      }      }      }      // Computes the hash value of a given board      public     static     int     computeHash  (  List   <  List   <  Character  >>     board  )     {      int     h     =     0  ;      for     (  int     i     =     0  ;     i      <     8  ;     i  ++  )     {      for     (  int     j     =     0  ;     j      <     8  ;     j  ++  )     {      if     (  board  .  get  (  i  ).  get  (  j  )     !=     '-'  )     {      int     piece     =     indexOf  (  board  .  get  (  i  ).  get  (  j  ));      h     ^=     ZobristTable  .  get  (  i  ).  get  (  j  ).  get  (  piece  );      }      }      }      return     h  ;      }      public     static     void     main  (  String  []     args  )     {      // Main Function      // Uppercase letters are white pieces      // Lowercase letters are black pieces      List   <  List   <  Character  >>     board     =     new     ArrayList   <>  ();      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       '-'       '-'       'K'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       'R'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'Q'       '-'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       '-'       '-'       'K'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       'P'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'p'       '-'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'p'       '-'       '-'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  'p'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'b'       '-'       '-'       'q'  )));      board  .  add  (  new     ArrayList   <>  (  Arrays  .  asList  (  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'n'       '-'       '-'       'k'  )));      initialise  ();      initTable  ();      int     hashValue     =     computeHash  (  board  );      System  .  out  .  println  (  'The hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );      // Move the white king to the left      char     piece     =     board  .  get  (  0  ).  get  (  3  );      board  .  get  (  0  ).  set  (  3       '-'  );      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  .  get  (  0  ).  get  (  3  ).  get  (  indexOf  (  piece  ));      board  .  get  (  0  ).  set  (  2       piece  );      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  .  get  (  0  ).  get  (  2  ).  get  (  indexOf  (  piece  ));      System  .  out  .  println  (  'The new hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );      // Undo the white king move      piece     =     board  .  get  (  0  ).  get  (  2  );      board  .  get  (  0  ).  set  (  2       '-'  );      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  .  get  (  0  ).  get  (  2  ).  get  (  indexOf  (  piece  ));      board  .  get  (  0  ).  set  (  3       piece  );      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  .  get  (  0  ).  get  (  3  ).  get  (  indexOf  (  piece  ));      System  .  out  .  println  (  'The new hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );      }   }   // This code is contributed by Vaibhav   
Python3
   # A program to illustrate Zobrist Hashing Algorithm   # python code implementation   import   random   # mt19937 mt(01234567);   # Generates a Random number from 0 to 2^64-1   def   randomInt  ():   min   =   0   max   =   pow  (  2     64  )   return   random  .  randint  (  min     max  )   # This function associates each piece with   # a number   def   indexOf  (  piece  ):   if   (  piece  ==  'P'  ):   return   0   elif   (  piece  ==  'N'  ):   return   1   elif   (  piece  ==  'B'  ):   return   2   elif   (  piece  ==  'R'  ):   return   3   elif   (  piece  ==  'Q'  ):   return   4   elif   (  piece  ==  'K'  ):   return   5   elif   (  piece  ==  'p'  ):   return   6   elif   (  piece  ==  'n'  ):   return   7   elif   (  piece  ==  'b'  ):   return   8   elif   (  piece  ==  'r'  ):   return   9   elif   (  piece  ==  'q'  ):   return   10   elif   (  piece  ==  'k'  ):   return   11   else  :   return   -  1   # Initializes the table   def   initTable  ():   # 8x8x12 array   ZobristTable   =   [[[  randomInt  ()   for   k   in   range  (  12  )]   for   j   in   range  (  8  )]   for   i   in   range  (  8  )]   return   ZobristTable   # Computes the hash value of a given board   def   computeHash  (  board     ZobristTable  ):   h   =   0   for   i   in   range  (  8  ):   for   j   in   range  (  8  ):   if   (  board  [  i  ][  j  ]   !=   '-'  ):   piece   =   indexOf  (  board  [  i  ][  j  ])   h   ^=   ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ][  piece  ]   return   h   # Main Function   # Uppercase letters are white pieces   # Lowercase letters are black pieces   board   =   [   '---K----'     '-R----Q-'     '--------'     '-P----p-'     '-----p--'     '--------'     'p---b--q'     '----n--k'   ]   ZobristTable   =   initTable  ()   hashValue   =   computeHash  (  board     ZobristTable  )   print  (  'The hash value is : '   +   str  (  hashValue  ))   #Move the white king to the left   piece   =   board  [  0  ][  3  ]   board  [  0  ]   =   list  (  board  [  0  ])   board  [  0  ][  3  ]   =   '-'   board  [  0  ]   =   ''  .  join  (  board  [  0  ])   hashValue   ^=   ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )]   board  [  0  ]   =   list  (  board  [  0  ])   board  [  0  ][  2  ]   =   piece   board  [  0  ]   =   ''  .  join  (  board  [  0  ])   hashValue   ^=   ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )]   print  (  'The new hash value is : '   +   str  (  hashValue  ))   # Undo the white king move   piece   =   board  [  0  ][  2  ]   board  [  0  ]   =   list  (  board  [  0  ])   board  [  0  ][  2  ]   =   '-'   board  [  0  ]   =   ''  .  join  (  board  [  0  ])   hashValue   ^=   ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )]   board  [  0  ]   =   list  (  board  [  0  ])   board  [  0  ][  3  ]   =   piece   board  [  0  ]   =   ''  .  join  (  board  [  0  ])   hashValue   ^=   ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )]   print  (  'The old hash value is : '   +   str  (  hashValue  ))   
C#
   using     System  ;   using     System.Collections  ;   using     System.Collections.Generic  ;   using     System.Linq  ;   // C# program for the above approach   // A program to illustrate Zobrist Hashing Algorithm   // javascript code implementation   class     HelloWorld     {      public     static     List   <  List   <  List   <  int  >>>     ZobristTable     =     new     List   <  List   <  List   <  int  >>>  ();      // mt19937 mt(01234567);      public     static     void     initialise  (){          for  (  int     i     =     0  ;     i      <     8  ;     i  ++  ){      ZobristTable  .  Add  (  new     List   <  List   <  int  >>  ());      for  (  int     j     =     0  ;     j      <     8  ;     j  ++  ){      ZobristTable  [  i  ].  Add  (  new     List   <  int  >  ());      for  (  int     k     =     0  ;     k      <     12  ;     k  ++  ){      ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ].  Add  (  0  );      }      }         }      }      // Generates a Random number from 0 to 2^64-1      public     static     int     randomInt  ()     {      int     min     =     0  ;      int     max     =     (  int  )  Math  .  Pow  (  2       64  );      Random     rnd     =     new     Random  ();      return     rnd  .  Next  ()     *     (  max     -     min  )     +     min  ;      }      // This function associates each piece with      // a number      public     static     int     indexOf  (  char     piece  )      {      if     (  piece  ==  'P'  )      return     0  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'N'  )      return     1  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'B'  )      return     2  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'R'  )      return     3  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'Q'  )      return     4  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'K'  )      return     5  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'p'  )      return     6  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'n'  )      return     7  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'b'  )      return     8  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'r'  )      return     9  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'q'  )      return     10  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'k'  )      return     11  ;      else      return     -  1  ;      }      // Initializes the table      public     static     void     initTable  ()      {      for     (  int     i     =     0  ;     i   <  8  ;     i  ++  ){      for  (  int     j     =     0  ;     j      <     8  ;     j  ++  ){      for  (  int     k     =     0  ;     k      <     12  ;     k  ++  ){      Random     rnd     =     new     Random  ();      ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ][  k  ]     =     rnd  .  Next  ();      }      }      }      }      // Computes the hash value of a given board      public     static     int     computeHash  (  List   <  List   <  char  >>     board  )      {      int     h     =     0  ;      for     (  int     i     =     0  ;     i   <  8  ;     i  ++  )      {      for     (  int     j     =     0  ;     j   <  8  ;     j  ++  )      {      if     (  board  [  i  ][  j  ]  !=  '-'  )      {      int     piece     =     indexOf  (  board  [  i  ][  j  ]);      h     ^=     ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ][  piece  ];      }      }      }      return     h  ;      }          static     void     Main  ()     {      // Main Function      // Uppercase letters are white pieces      // Lowercase letters are black pieces      List   <  List   <  char  >>     board     =     new     List   <  List   <  char  >>  ();      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       '-'       '-'       'K'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       'R'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'Q'       '-'  });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       '-'       '-'       'K'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       'P'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'p'       '-'  });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'p'       '-'       '-'       });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'  });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  'p'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'b'       '-'       '-'       'q'  });      board  .  Add  (  new     List   <  char  >  (){  '-'       '-'       '-'       '-'       'n'       '-'       '-'       'k'  });      initialise  ();      initTable  ();              int     hashValue     =     computeHash  (  board  );      Console  .  WriteLine  (  'The hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );      //Move the white king to the left      char     piece     =     board  [  0  ][  3  ];      board  [  0  ][  3  ]     =     '-'  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      board  [  0  ][  2  ]     =     piece  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      Console  .  WriteLine  (  'The new hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );      // Undo the white king move      piece     =     board  [  0  ][  2  ];      board  [  0  ][  2  ]     =     '-'  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      board  [  0  ][  3  ]     =     piece  ;      hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];      Console  .  WriteLine  (  'The old hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );      }   }   // The code is contributed by Nidhi goel.    
JavaScript
   // A program to illustrate Zobrist Hashing Algorithm   // javascript code implementation   let     ZobristTable     =     new     Array  (  8  );   for  (  let     i     =     0  ;     i      <     8  ;     i  ++  ){      ZobristTable  [  i  ]     =     new     Array  (  8  );   }   for  (  let     i     =     0  ;     i      <     8  ;     i  ++  ){      for  (  let     j     =     0  ;     j      <     8  ;     j  ++  ){      ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ]     =     new     Array  (  12  );      }   }   // mt19937 mt(01234567);       // Generates a Random number from 0 to 2^64-1   function     randomInt  ()     {      let     min     =     0  ;      let     max     =     Math  .  pow  (  2       64  );      return     Math  .  floor  (  Math  .  random  ()     *     (  max     -     min  )     +     min  );   }       // This function associates each piece with   // a number   function     indexOf  (  piece  )   {      if     (  piece  ==  'P'  )      return     0  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'N'  )      return     1  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'B'  )      return     2  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'R'  )      return     3  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'Q'  )      return     4  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'K'  )      return     5  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'p'  )      return     6  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'n'  )      return     7  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'b'  )      return     8  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'r'  )      return     9  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'q'  )      return     10  ;      if     (  piece  ==  'k'  )      return     11  ;      else      return     -  1  ;   }       // Initializes the table   function     initTable  ()   {      for     (  let     i     =     0  ;     i   <  8  ;     i  ++  )      for     (  let     j     =     0  ;     j   <  8  ;     j  ++  )      for     (  let     k     =     0  ;     k   <  12  ;     k  ++  ){      ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ][  k  ]     =     randomInt  ();      }       }       // Computes the hash value of a given board   function     computeHash  (  board  )   {      let     h     =     0  ;      for     (  let     i     =     0  ;     i   <  8  ;     i  ++  )      {      for     (  let     j     =     0  ;     j   <  8  ;     j  ++  )      {      if     (  board  [  i  ][  j  ]  !=  '-'  )      {      let     piece     =     indexOf  (  board  [  i  ][  j  ]);      h     ^=     ZobristTable  [  i  ][  j  ][  piece  ];      }      }      }      return     h  ;   }       // Main Function   // Uppercase letters are white pieces   // Lowercase letters are black pieces   let     board     =     [      '---K----'        '-R----Q-'        '--------'        '-P----p-'        '-----p--'        '--------'        'p---b--q'        '----n--k'   ];   initTable  ();   let     hashValue     =     computeHash  (  board  );   console  .  log  (  'The hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );   //Move the white king to the left   let     piece     =     board  [  0  ][  3  ];   board  [  0  ]     =     board  [  0  ].  split  (  ''  );   board  [  0  ][  3  ]     =     '-'  ;   board  [  0  ]     =     board  [  0  ].  join  (  ''  );   hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];   board  [  0  ]     =     board  [  0  ].  split  (  ''  );   board  [  0  ][  2  ]     =     piece  ;   board  [  0  ]     =     board  [  0  ].  join  (  ''  );   hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];   console  .  log  (  'The new hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );   // Undo the white king move   piece     =     board  [  0  ][  2  ];   board  [  0  ]     =     board  [  0  ].  split  (  ''  );   board  [  0  ][  2  ]     =     '-'  ;   board  [  0  ]     =     board  [  0  ].  join  (  ''  );   hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  2  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];   board  [  0  ][  3  ]     =     piece  ;   hashValue     ^=     ZobristTable  [  0  ][  3  ][  indexOf  (  piece  )];   console  .  log  (  'The old hash value is : '     +     hashValue  );   // The code is contributed by Nidhi goel.    

출력 :

The hash value is : 14226429382419125366 The new hash value is : 15124945578233295113 The old hash value is : 14226429382419125366